Westerville in Review - May 2025
West of East of Africa - May 1, 2025
After 40 years on Africa Road, John and Joyce Starkey moved out of their longtime home to make way for the extension of Westar Boulevard—a project that will link to the 88-acre East of Africa development. The city purchased the property and covered moving expenses, with demolition of the Starkey home and barn scheduled for May 15. Meanwhile, two outbuildings near the historic Sharp House were removed to accommodate the same road extension, though the Sharp House itself remains protected due to its significance on the Underground Railroad.
Fire Suppression Next Phase - May 2, 2025
The next phase of Uptown infrastructure improvements began in May, with contractors delivering materials to upgrade Hanby Alley behind East Home Street businesses. The project includes new water and drainage lines to support future fire suppression systems, underground utility relocation, and fiber conduit installation. In a separate event, a massive Hitachi Energy circuit breaker passed through Uptown, likely bound for a regional substation upgrade.
270 Huber Village Fire - May 2, 2025
Emergency responders were called to 270 Huber Village Blvd. in May for a kitchen fire—the latest in a string of troubling incidents at the home, including a death investigation, discovery of an IED, and recent drug-related arrests. That same day, a small fire at OhioHealth’s Polaris Parkway location triggered an evacuation, though the sprinkler system quickly contained the blaze. In other developments, construction began on the new Middlefield Bank site at Cleveland Avenue and Altair Parkway, part of a land-swap deal that will move the bank out of Uptown and allow the city to take ownership of a historic State Street property.
Brunch Begs For More - May 5, 2025
The Westerville News critiqued brunch at High Bank Distillery, where the much-anticipated Hot Honey Chicken & Biscuits and deviled eggs fell short of expectations, lacking the flavor and creativity promised by the menu. Business news briefs.
Fox in the Snow Conversion Begins - May 6, 2025
Demolition began at 79 S. State Street to convert the former Fusian and Cucinova location into the city’s first Fox in the Snow café. Meanwhile, a pickup truck crashed into a home on Allview Road, condemning the property and resulting in DUI charges for the driver. Otterbein University celebrated 590 graduates during a rainy but spirited indoor commencement ceremony. And in lighter fare, The Westerville News' weekly Green Grape Report praised a sweet, crisp Chilean batch from Kroger.
City Council Approves CEDs and Energy Contracts. Liquor Ballot Issues Approved. Genoa Fire Levy Passes - May 7, 2025
Westerville City Council advanced key development and energy initiatives, approving two new Community Entertainment Districts in Uptown and the Westar/East of Africa area to expand liquor permit access and attract restaurants and entertainment venues. Council also secured increased natural gas capacity and approved new solar projects, starting with solar panels at the community center, while extending the city’s “block and index” energy procurement strategy through 2035. Voters approved liquor sales expansions for Cardinal Pizza and the private club No Soliciting. Election results also saw Genoa Township approve a fire levy renewal and increase, while Blendon Township’s police levy narrowly failed.
Africa Road Sanitary Sewer Delays - May 8, 2025
Unexpected underground conditions and heavy spring rains delayed sanitary sewer installation along Africa Road, pushing the project well beyond its original April 28 completion date. Crews encountered glacial till, waterlogged soil, and unmarked utility conduits, requiring additional pumping and trench reinforcement. Separately, a car crash on North West Street damaged underground power infrastructure, cutting electricity to the Towns on the Greenway development and closing the road for repairs.
Fire Suppression Next Phase and pH Changes on Westerville Farm Fields - May 9, 2025
Westerville advanced two major infrastructure projects in May. Crews began laying copper water lines in Hanby and Haywood Alleys as part of a multi-phase fire suppression initiative aimed at protecting Uptown’s historic district. The project, spurred by past fire risk and limited sprinkler systems, will offer grants for businesses that connect. Separately, the city launched a lime sludge removal effort at the Water Treatment Plant, with over 700 tanker loads of treated lime set for land application on local farms. Upgrades to the east lagoon—including a new synthetic liner and concrete ramps—will improve safety, efficiency, and groundwater protection.
Traffic Study Data Update - May 10, 2025
As part of ongoing efforts to improve infrastructure, Westerville launched a traffic study in Uptown in April, installing tall sensors along State Street to evaluate signal timing and enhance vehicle flow through the district. Meanwhile, progress continued on the $21 million City Hall renovation project, which will unify two municipal buildings with a new enclosed walkway. The modernization effort, the first major overhaul since 1987, is set to centralize city operations and add parking. During construction, city offices have been temporarily relocated, and events like the Saturday Uptown Market have moved to alternate venues.
Water Tank Getting Paint. First Farm Market Opens. Mother’s Day Observance - May 12, 2025
The long-delayed repainting of the Hoff Woods water tower began under a new contractor, with BRZ Coatings expected to complete the project by June after the original contractor defaulted. The Westerville Farm Market opened at Africa Road and Polaris Parkway, offering flowers and fresh popcorn, with produce expected later in the season. Meanwhile, the Hurst family and others marked Mother’s Day at Blendon Central Cemetery through quiet acts of remembrance. On a lighter note, The Green Grape Report highlighted Walmart’s Chilean grapes as the season’s sweetest and most satisfying to date.
Crashes. Road Reconstruction and Closing - May 13, 2025
Two traffic incidents occurred on May 12 in Westerville: a woman was hospitalized after her vehicle overturned in a two-car crash at Sunbury Road and Central College, and a bicyclist was injured in a hit-and-run near McCorkle Boulevard and County Line Road. Police are continuing to investigate both incidents. In infrastructure news, sidewalk and curb reconstruction progressed along Birmingham Road. At the same time, a temporary closure of Home Street was scheduled for May 14 to connect new water lines for Uptown’s fire suppression system.
Police Accreditation and Park’s Changes - May 14, 2025
Westerville Police Department highlighted its CALEA accreditation progress during a City Council work session, emphasizing policy improvements, accountability, and national recognition, placing the department among just 69 accredited agencies in Ohio. Parks and Recreation also introduced a major redesign of its online registration platform, focusing on usability and reducing resident confusion ahead of high-demand program signups. In public safety news, the cyclist injured in a hit-and-run at McCorkle and County Line was identified as a 58-year-old man suffering serious injuries. Police later arrested Cathy Roberson, who admitted to being in the area but claimed she thought she had hit a construction sign.
Home Stays Closed. City Hall Update - May 15, 2025
Home Street remained closed as crews worked to replace brick pavers following earlier utility connections tied to Uptown’s fire suppression system upgrades. The rain-caused delay extended what was initially planned as a one-day closure. Meanwhile, visible progress continued on Westerville’s $21 million City Hall renovation, including rooftop work on the building’s cupola and excavation for a new basement space. Departments remain temporarily relocated. On Schrock Road, a two-vehicle crash near Cooper Road caused significant traffic delays during the evening commute, with one person treated at the scene for minor injuries.
Police Chief Retires. Westerville’s Knife Throwing Champion. Saturday Market Changes - May 16, 2025
Westerville Police Chief Charles “Cappy” Chandler officially retired after a 30-year law enforcement career, including 24 years in Westerville. Now leading Morrow County Area Transit, Chandler reflected on his tenure, citing major accomplishments such as the creation of an academy, a therapy canine program, and departmental accreditation. Assistant Chief Holly Murchland is serving as acting chief while the city begins its search for a replacement. In other updates, Westerville’s Coleman Bates claimed the World Knife Throwing Championship title, defeating a two-time world champion using mental rehearsal techniques. The Westerville Saturday Farmers Market will relocate to South State Street during the City Hall renovation. Also this week, community members and students gathered outside Robert Frost Elementary in support of public education amid concerns over proposed state funding cuts.
Water Treatment Pond Repairs Begun - May 17, 2025
Westerville began repairs on a leaking lime holding pond at its water treatment plant, addressing long-term wear that threatened nearby Alum Creek. Crews are removing accumulated lime sludge and applying it to the Braun and Otterbein farms in accordance with EPA-approved land application guidelines. New liners and concrete ramps will be installed to prevent future leaks and improve maintenance access. In community events, the Tunnel to Towers 5K is set for May 18 at the Westerville Sports Complex, supporting first responders and military families. Friday Night Uptown also continued, with youth band Short Fuse performing at Rotary Park.
Summer Market Feast Begins With Steak and Strawberries - May 19, 2025
The Saturday Farmers Market opened with an early bounty of local produce, including strawberries from King’s and Rhoads farms, lettuce from High Point Produce, and beef from C.A.B.B. Farm—leading to a home-cooked seasonal feast reviewed in Eating My Way Through The Saturday Market. Separately, the Green Grape Report praised Aldi’s unusually large and sweet Mexican-grown Sugar Crisp grapes. The Tunnel to Towers 5K drew participants through central Westerville, honoring first responders and military families, with a massive American flag suspended between ladder trucks as part of the tribute.
School Board Budget Woes Continue - May 20, 2025
The Westerville School Board approved a five-year financial forecast that projects a budget deficit by 2029, with staffing and spending reductions planned in response to declining revenue and a failed levy. Cuts include 30+ positions across all employee groups, a major administrative restructuring, and rescinded capital project funds. No new levy has been announced for 2025. Meanwhile, the Africa Road sanitary sewer project is nearly complete, pending final paving work. Phase two—requiring a closure at Polaris Parkway—is scheduled to begin soon, though rainy weather may delay both phases.
Sharp House Gets Renovation Manager. Africa Road To Open Temporarily. - May 21, 2025
Westerville has appointed a project manager to lead the stabilization and renovation planning for the historic Sharp House, located within the East of Africa development site. The six-month effort aims to prepare the Underground Railroad-linked structure for potential commercial use while preserving its historical integrity. Meanwhile, construction on Africa Road is nearing temporary completion, with plans to reopen the road through Memorial Day weekend.
Fourth Friday and Field of Heroes This Weekend in Westerville - May 22, 2025
Westerville’s Fourth Friday festival season begins May 23, featuring music, food, art, over 100 vendors, and science-themed activities. Events will continue monthly through October. The Field of Heroes returns to the Westerville Sports Complex for Memorial Day weekend, displaying 3,500 dedicated flags and hosting the Traveling Vietnam Memorial Wall.
Uptown Pin Oak Dies and Africa Road To Reopen Friday - May 23, 2025
A 60-year-old oak tree on Winter Street near Java Central was removed after failing to show signs of life this spring. Its decline is attributed to recent construction, and no replacement has yet been planted. The nearby “Heritage Oak” is showing signs of stress as well. Africa Road is scheduled to reopen late Friday following completion of sewer work and paving.
Africa Opens and First Fourth Photos - May 24, 2025
Africa Road officially reopened to through traffic on May 24 after nearly a month of delays caused by weather and complications during sanitary sewer installation. The final barriers were removed in the afternoon, restoring access between County Line and the East of Africa project area.
Field of Heroes, EMWTTSFM, and Grapes - May 26, 2025
Gary Gardiner shared a follow-up to his Saturday Farmers Market food review, highlighting a strawberry salad made with greens from Hammerie Farm and strawberries from Rhoads, topped with honeyed nuts and a mango vinaigrette. Paired with beef tenderloin, the dish exemplified his view that salads can be part of a main course rather than just a starter.
In this week’s Green Grape Report, Gardiner noted that while Aldi again had the lowest price at $2.15/lb, the grapes were significantly smaller and less sweet than the previous week. He’s begun using digital tools for more precise measurement and explained how environmental and handling variables contribute to week-to-week variation in grape quality.
Pond Repair Progressing and Field of Heroes Final Honors - May 27, 2025
Westerville’s water treatment plant is undergoing a major cleanup of a lime holding pond near Alum Creek, prompted by signs of leakage and deterioration. Crews are removing lime sludge before installing a new liner to prevent environmental contamination. The lime, rich in calcium carbonate, is being applied to nearby farmland to improve soil.
Meanwhile, the Field of Heroes concluded its Memorial Day observance with a solemn ceremony featuring military honors and the removal of over 3,000 dedicated flags. This year’s tribute included a replica of the Vietnam Veterans Memorial Wall and focused on honoring Vietnam-era service members.
First Hay Cut and Zoning Code Change Proposed - May 28, 2025
Farmer Kevin Scott reported a strong start to hay season with 31 round bales harvested from Otterbein University land near Cooper Road, a significant increase from last year’s total of 10. The field, one of several he manages amid encroaching development, remains a rare piece of working farmland in Westerville. Meanwhile, the city’s Planning Commission is reviewing zoning code updates that would ease restrictions on accessory structures such as sheds and ADUs, including reduced setbacks, increased height limits, and the removal of outdated distance rules.
Sludge On Otterbein Fields. Commission Tables Dunkin On Polaris. - May 29, 2025
Following a successful hay harvest, three fields near Cooper Road — including Otterbein University land — were treated with lime sludge from Westerville’s water treatment plant as part of the city’s environmental reuse efforts. The sludge, a byproduct of water softening, helps restore soil pH and improve fertility. Meanwhile, the Planning Commission approved zoning code changes to ease rules on accessory structures and granted final approval for a Northwest Bank branch along Polaris Parkway. A proposal for a nearby Dunkin’ with a drive-thru was tabled due to incomplete design and traffic-related concerns.
Uptown Flowers And Clues To The Answers - May 30, 2025
Westerville’s Uptown hanging baskets received a botanical refresh this year, replacing petunias with a mix including wax begonias and sweet potato vines, part of the city’s effort to improve plant health and visual appeal. Meanwhile, a new interactive event, “Uptown Clue,” begins May 31, offering comedic mystery walking tours through Uptown on Saturdays. The Farmers Market continues its season at a new location near COhatch and North High Brewing, with vendors, music, and limited parking options available through September.
Road Repairs, Closing, Completed, and the Sunday Concert Series Begins - May 31, 2025
The Main Street Bridge over I-71 has reopened with new bike infrastructure, while roadwork continues as Africa Road is set to close south of Polaris Parkway for sewer installation and Birmingham Road prepares for repaving. Meanwhile, the Westerville Summer Concert Series begins June 1 at Alum Creek Park Amphitheater, featuring a diverse lineup including local jazz ensembles, tribute acts, and the Westerville Symphony, with performances running weekly through August 24.
The Westerville News is a reader-supported publication by Gary Gardiner, a lifelong journalist who believes hyper-local reporting is the future of news. This publication focuses exclusively on Westerville—its local news, influence on Central Ohio, and how surrounding areas shape the community.
Explore more hyper-local reporting by subscribing to The Hilliard Beacon, Civic Capacity, Marysville Matters, The Ohio Roundtable, Shelby News Reporter, This Week in Toledo, and Into the Morning by Krista Steele.
